Because you are creating a moral dimension where there is none. For an animal there is no difference between an animal it feeds on or a fruit, because it doesn't know better.
The only factor with a concept of morals in the world of animal prey - carnivore - you eating the carnivore is you.
If you demand to eat a carnivore, you give money to the human who enslaved the carnivore and condemned the herbivores to be fed in by the carnivore.
In order to be able to eat the carnivore, you condemn both herbivore and carnivore to enslavement and death. You are the morally doubtful actor here. Not the carnivore.
Let me guess: you really, really want to eat meat, right?
No worries, I do, too. But I don't deny myself herbivores. Maybe take a timeout from your rule and eat steak, too, until you come up with a better thought out rule.
That being said, I think veganism is the way to go, I am just not strong enough.
If you ever decide you're ready, see if I'm still using this username. I'm the "help people on their journey" kind of vegan, not the "bully the meat-eaters" kind that are so infamous. I won't judge you. I'll just give you recipes and ideas for easy food.
You call me ridiculous while saying I'm demanding to eat carnivores, which I never said, I eat omnivores which are not farm raised on eating herbivores, lol.
So, following that train of reasoning, the most moral option would be cannibalism, as humans do the most active intentional harm to other living things by a massive amount, no other animal even comes close to us.
I mean, I can lay out the train of logic for you, it's not a big stretch.
You say that you have decided that the moral way to draw the line of what animals to eat and what not to eat is to base it on the harm that creature does to other living things.
Well, one animal is at the top of that list, number one with a bullet. You can spot one in any mirror.
So, assuming that you don't in fact think you should be eating people, then perhaps you aren't in truth basing your choices on the criteria you claim to be using.
1
u/BumWink 4d ago
I don't want to eat living things that do no active harm to other living things.
I have no qualms eating a chicken that would happily kill & eat mice, frogs, cannabalize, etc. or fish that practically all kill to eat.
How is that so ridiculous to understand?