r/Damnthatsinteresting 8d ago

Video Coal mining

45.3k Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3.0k

u/AnonymousTimewaster 8d ago

Just the shiny black part

680

u/LastTreestar 8d ago

I wonder exactly how much that's worth.

2.0k

u/AdditionalMixture697 8d ago

Like $100 per ton

1.3k

u/COC_410 8d ago

Wow you’re right. I thought it was a stupid Reddit comment.

683

u/AdditionalMixture697 8d ago

A diamond in the rough these days. Carry on.

200

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

116

u/bald_firebeard 8d ago

There'll be peace when you are done

94

u/Thefear1984 8d ago

Lay your weary head to rest, don’t you cry no more.

35

u/Intelligent-Site721 8d ago

[guitar solo]

1

u/Xetiw 7d ago

Dont you cry no more

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/GingusBinguss 8d ago

I see what you did there

3

u/zomphlotz 8d ago

That was one of the better ones, huh?

2

u/Ok_Conflict_8900 8d ago

Man, I must be getting older. CauseI feel like reddit 5 years ago was more credible but with more dragon

1

u/GrandNibbles 8d ago

Was this ever the norm though be honest

1

u/Big_Salt371 7d ago

It's more like a coal in the smooth

They're both carbon.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LuukTheSlayer 7d ago

nah i buy it for like 700 euro per ton :(

334

u/ToxicPilgrim 8d ago

that doesn't seem worth it at alllllllll

491

u/Void_Speaker 8d ago

it's worth it if you pay the workers like $10 per ton

7

u/ImNotEazy 8d ago

I’m a miner. Gravel is only 20 bucks a ton. But when you pump out 1500 tons per hour it should start making sense.

76

u/xPofsx 8d ago

The tool is worth more than the coal lmao

289

u/DayPretend8294 8d ago

That’s how it is in EVERY industry homie. The stove the chefs make your McDonald’s burger on are like 20k on the low end.

151

u/Patient_Bug_8275 8d ago

Wait until they find out how much an automotive assembly plant costs to make

50

u/ThatLeetGuy 8d ago

Or the cost of a Plastic Mold Injection die to make Warhammer miniatures.

12

u/RandomPenquin1337 8d ago

Less than the miniatures.

One industry this doesn't apply to lol

4

u/A_Really_Bad_Lawyer 8d ago

Dont speak of my plastic crack this low.

2

u/Neurojazz 7d ago

Go back to lead ones, they taste much nicer.

6

u/FTownRoad 7d ago

An oil refinery costs billions but then they go and sell gasoline for only $3/gallon. What idiots!

3

u/Whathaole 7d ago

Back in 1987, when Chrysler bought Jeep from AMC, the plan was to kill off Jeep. Chrysler bought it because AMC had recently spent just over one billion dollars building a brand new assembly plant for Jeep. Chrysler paid 1.5 billion for all Jeep assets. If an automotive assembly plant was a billion dollars to build 4 decades ago, today’s cost is astronomical. Somewhere in the vicinity of $15,500,000,000 USD.

6

u/alpine_zephyr 8d ago

I like the way you called a McDs burger cook a chef, i'm sure they appreciate that.

3

u/DayPretend8294 8d ago

Hey man, whatever makes them happy, I don’t want unhappy McDonald’s people making my food haha

1

u/Drow_Femboy 7d ago

"food" is similarly generous ;)

6

u/No9Fishing 8d ago

Chefs???

1

u/DayPretend8294 8d ago

Cooks sorry lol

3

u/No9Fishing 8d ago

You’re not even wrong technically I just hate McDonald’s :/

2

u/MNgrown2299 8d ago

One analytical machine at my work is like $200,000 lmao

3

u/DayPretend8294 7d ago

A fabrication company I worked for spent close to 6 million on a laser CNC machine to get delivered and installed from like Sweden or something. The first thing they cut on it was a dinosaur out of a 1/8th piece of scrap stainless lmao

1

u/aggressive_seal 8d ago

We're using the term "chef" very loosely here.

1

u/Whathaole 7d ago

One of the 7 intaglio presses in existence, that US one dollar bills (and all other US currencies) are printed on.

1

u/Holiday-Pay193 7d ago

That's why they want to seize the means of production.

0

u/xPofsx 8d ago

Yeah but you can't steal a friggin stove

7

u/DenseStomach6605 8d ago

Watch me!

1

u/DirtLight134710 8d ago

Just go for the ice cream machine. It's worth around 2k

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Colossal_Penis_Haver 8d ago

I use a quarter of a million dollars of equipment to do a few thousand dollars of work every day.

The people who make big money are the people who sell the tools, not the ones that use them!

35

u/Asleep_Trick_4740 8d ago

The machine that constitutes the first step in making a microchip costs 200 million dollars.

A microchip is far cheaper than that.

19

u/InflatableMaidDoll 8d ago

and there are like 20 steps after that. microchip production is crazy.

7

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted]

4

u/Tack122 7d ago

Gotta start with macrochips.

26

u/CrossP 8d ago

The overhead'll kill you in mining.

8

u/FBI_NSA_DHS_CIA 8d ago

Ooh this guy got jokes

1

u/Academic_Ad5143 8d ago

It’s a lot to bear.

14

u/Tenthul 8d ago

Herein, you may find a redditor learning the origins of the phrase "gotta spend money to make money"

3

u/Darkhelmet3000 8d ago

You work 16 tons and what do you get? Another day older and deeper in debt…

5

u/Igottamake 8d ago

There’ll be pay in their pocket toniiiiiiiight, there’ll be food on the table toniiiiiight

2

u/matt08220ify 8d ago

Exactly what we're seeing here. At least one thing is for sure, these guys are making less than us minimum wage

1

u/Skilldibop 7d ago

and apparently don't bother providing them any PPE...

193

u/Loud_Interview4681 8d ago

Average miner produces 7 tons of coal a day. That is $700 or about 200,000 a year in production. Ofcourse the miner only takes home 40-50k. (assuming labor regulations)

167

u/Already_taken_1021 8d ago

The average US coal miner makes about $80k, considering they mostly lived in inexpensive places, that’s pretty good pay. I can’t imagine a job that I’d rather have less though

119

u/HowAManAimS 8d ago

But they are destroying their health and likely live in an area without good hospitals

60

u/motorider500 8d ago

Some make it a longgg time. A few of my wife’s relatives were active miners and lived into their late 80’s and early 90’s. Rough life though. And that specific area has decent hospitals. Go figure .

2

u/fatherofpugs12 7d ago

That’s amazing. Every miner in my family history didn’t make it past 60ish, if that. Decent hospitals too! I mean they also drank a ton but when you mine 🤷

2

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted]

1

u/HowAManAimS 7d ago

I've never seen Zoolander. I only know it as the movie with the meme "but why male models?"

1

u/Internal-Owl-505 8d ago

Mining in the U.S. and Europe is a highly mechanized process.

It is no more destructive than, say, digging road tunnels.

4

u/spaceforcerecruit 8d ago

Except for the black lung

-1

u/CurryNarwhal 8d ago

They have the "freedom" to move somewhere else or do other jobs ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

26

u/Molotov_Glocktail 8d ago

Once you pay them as little as possible, then you start removing all the safety regulations to save the company money.

Capitalism!

4

u/AslowLearn 8d ago

Free sinkholes 100 feet wide and 60 feet deep!

2

u/CeleryRight4133 8d ago

How about razor blade taste tester?

2

u/shart-attack1 8d ago

In Aus there are heaps of people trying to get into the industry, not many other jobs that will pay 150k for 6 months work with no uni degree.

1

u/praetorian1979 8d ago

I'd rather be the squeegee guy at a peep show...

1

u/ElliotNess 8d ago

So they create ~$700 directly through their physical labour, but only receive $300? Why? That's $400 missing, and there are hundreds of him at the company. Who decides what to do with the extra 40 thousands of dollars every day?

5

u/fluchtpunkt Interested 8d ago

Office workers, maintenance workers, materials, fuel, electricity, tools have to be paid too. Then there’s taxes, insurances.

You will have a lot more expenses than wages for “productive” personnel.

And some obviously goes to profit.

1

u/McGillis_is_a_Char 8d ago

Those places are inexpensive to live in because there isn't a whole lot around. When you have to drive 100 miles to the nearest college, and 50 miles to the nearest hospital bigger than a Whole Foods, of course it is cheaper to live there. Add in the poison water supply in some coal mining towns and cost of living goes way down until you die of cancer.

→ More replies (4)

37

u/chickenwithapulley 8d ago

I work in Open Cut, and this small amount is insane to me. We pull over 5 million tons a year.

6

u/neuralbeans 8d ago

per worker?

27

u/bluppitybloop 8d ago

Open cut is referring to mining from the surface. Basically, remove all the garbage earth that is above the coal. Then remove the coal, and once the coal is gone, you put the garbage material back.

It's all done using a fleet of heavy machinery, and you can't really quantify a "tonnage per person" in the same sense as you can in this video.

1

u/neuralbeans 8d ago

Ah, it also involve a lot of explosives, right? I asked because the comment about 7 tons never said how many tons are extracted in total per year, just per worker.

1

u/chickenwithapulley 7d ago

Hey mate, yeah so, it does involve Drilling and blasting. So our site has (and you can look these up) for moving Dirt and Coal: 2 Draglines, 2 Rope Shovels, 8 Excavators (of multiple sizes, Leibherr 9800, 9600, 996 and others) and around 50 Trucks of varying size, mostly Ultraclass and slightly smaller, ( Komatsu 930e, Cat 797, 794ac, 793). Including maintenance it's around 700 workers, including staff and Maintenance. It's pretty incredible stuff, you should check it out.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Palocles 8d ago

The guys in the video aren't making $50k.

7

u/AThickMatOfHair 8d ago

This is not the "average", this is some unregulated illegal mine. This shit has been completely mechanized for the past half century in developed countries.

1

u/Loud_Interview4681 7d ago

The numbers jump to 25+ tons/person once you bring in heavy machinery and widely range upward. By hand? 7 tons is generously low but still reasonable.

3

u/Wheel-Reinventor 8d ago

assuming labor regulations

I doubt there is any for the guys in the video, seeing how they have 0 protection against anything.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/InUsConfidery 8d ago

Black lung kicks in around 20 years old. Spend it quick!

2

u/dogfan44 8d ago

Not average coal miner….if they work in a depressed area I’m sure that’s close to what they make right now but most coal miners I know have a base salary of around 90 to 100k and have the option to work more up to around 150k. It’s hard work but they aren’t servants. The majority have good jobs.

1

u/Anuclano 8d ago

It looks like you take 7 tons and the whole cavern will collapse. For sure they know how to do this, the most of fatalities in coal mines are related to methane explosions, not to usual extraction.

1

u/saposapot 8d ago

It can’t be this type of miner doing it by hand, right? No way they haul 7 tons per person working like that

1

u/Loud_Interview4681 7d ago

That video was 2 minutes long, I would imagine so as they mine a lot more with heavy machinery.

1

u/havingsomedifficulty 8d ago

Don’t forget about the take home black lung

1

u/Loud_Interview4681 7d ago

Theft from the workplace? Deducted from pay.

1

u/Mediocre-Bet-3949 4d ago

Average miner produces 7 tonnes of coal per day?

Does he also carry it out? Because that sounds like a job for a lot more than one man...

1

u/Loud_Interview4681 4d ago

Carrying it out and loading I think the record was 66 tons in a day (24hrs) with 15+ being standard for experienced miners per shift. About 1 pallet worth per ton. It is certainly doable.

→ More replies (10)

99

u/BoringJuiceBox 8d ago

Whoever owns the mine that does zero labor thinks it’s worth it, but of course the working class people are paid pennies on the dollar for what their time is worth. We are slaves.

4

u/VoltOneSix 8d ago

Shackled not by chains, but by debt

0

u/samuelazers 8d ago

they should've just learned programming and invested in Bitcoin /s

-10

u/informat7 8d ago edited 8d ago

This is such a Reddit comment. Coal miners get paid little because coal isn't super profitable. The industry averages a 10% profit margin.

9

u/FirexJkxFire 8d ago

How astute. I too noticed this was a comment made on reddit

5

u/Avoidable_Accident 8d ago

Uh oh, get ready for the onslaught of liberal haters who have no real job and nothing better to do!

0

u/End_Capitalism 8d ago

Here's a hint: there is abso-fucking-lutely no possible "because" that can justify slavery wages. You're not allowed to pay slave wages because otherwise you wouldn't be profitable.

"But then we would need to charge more for our products! And if we did that, nobody would buy it because coal is filthy and inefficient and other energy forms are getting so cheap!"

THEN THE COAL INDUSTRY SHOULD FUCKING CHOKE AND DIE.

8

u/dr4gon2000 8d ago

Coal miners make like 60k in places like West Virginia where the living wage literally is the federal minimum wage. They are paid plenty well for what they do, that's why they do it lol.

6

u/AuroraFinem 8d ago

Yeah I don’t understand how people’s first reaction to “I can’t pay people a livable wage because this industry isn’t profitable enough” is so often “Job creator!” And not “the industry shouldn’t exist”.

Not all industries need to exist, if people aren’t willing to pay the necessary price to pay a living wage, then the market is over saturated or non-viable. There’s some circumstances where we should involve ourselves like trying to promote clean energy or subsidizing research into new industries, but we shouldn’t just be propping up unsustainable industries except when necessary like food

3

u/spiderhater4 8d ago

Gemini tells me you can put 20 kg of coal into an average bucket. 1 metric ton is thus 50 buckets. So that's $2 per bucket of coal. Still not a lot. With big chunks, the bucket would fill relatively quickly. But surely the workers would only see a fraction of that money.

1

u/TheOvershear 8d ago

This is why these places run on MASSIVE subsidies, practically run on them.

1

u/Cassandraofastroya 8d ago

Well in not fucked countries you basically have a machine that does this and conveyerbelts it out of the mine

1

u/BarrierX 7d ago

And after all that work and effort, we just burn it!

→ More replies (22)

3

u/Thick-Tip9255 8d ago

Hahaha. We're killing our planet for $100 per ton...

1

u/BeardyMcBeardyBeard 6d ago

But wind turbines are ugly and solar isn't worth it and muh freedom

/s because who the fuck knows these days

4

u/FloppyObelisk 8d ago

Utility companies buy them by the train load. I did an audit for one and they paid $13 per ton. So if you get a lump of coal for Christmas it’s fitting that it’s literally worth nothing.

1

u/Gawwse 8d ago

Looking at that slab of cool dropping about how much does that weigh? 50 lbs? I’m just curious. Trying to understand the amount of coal that would be a ton.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/neoadam 7d ago

Wow makes me wonder how it is profitable to mine coal, excluding people wanting cheap dirty energy, but for the person extracting it, they must be paid like slaves

1

u/Sigon_91 7d ago

I paid 350$ per tone lately in UE. Welcome to communism

1

u/Horror-Pear 8d ago

Bituminous, sure. But anthracite is about double that, if you're lucky.

→ More replies (2)

177

u/Flaky_Guitar9018 8d ago

About 100$/ton, so 10 cents a kilo.

Not exactly a money shot

68

u/No-Mail-8565 8d ago

I was thinking about that. How tf can that be profitable. I buy a bag here for 2 dollars.

49

u/mmob18 8d ago

well, relative to the purchasing power of the companies that ultimately use the fuel, these guys are extracting it for free.

13

u/Vegetable-Suit4992 8d ago

Also burning it is heavily subsidized by most governments, because the cost from the massive damage it will cause our civilization is just discounted as a "future generation problem".

8

u/EldraziAnnihalator 8d ago

As it should, I'm living right now, let grown up kids worry about the environment once I myself am slowly turning into coal.

5

u/SnooPickles4465 8d ago

First I understand this is sarcasm but I'm going to rain on your parade anyway.

Coal itself is made from ancient forests that have died and been buried underground for millions of years usually it happens in sedimentary basins but this is an oversimplification for time saving.

2

u/Lou_C_Fer 7d ago

Yep. We aren't burning dinosaurs. We are burning the carbon left over from the forests you mentioned.

2

u/Lime1028 5d ago

Should also be clarified that all this dates to the Carboniferus period, and it's a quirk of evolution that it exists at all.

It won't happen again. Fossil fuels are not renewable even over millions of years.

1

u/Swimming-Scholar-675 7d ago

to be fair, that was how it worked out for the west lmfao

49

u/LiftbackChico 8d ago

Because power companies burn it to generate electricity and will buy it by the boatloads

3

u/Starfire2313 8d ago

Which means we are the ones ultimately paying for it because the electric companies must be making profits to stay in business.

Of course that’s obvious. But for whatever reason the thread was questioning it.

1

u/less_unique_username 8d ago

The consumers would still be the ones paying for the coal even if the companies were somehow operating at zero profit

1

u/Reasonable-World9 7d ago

Well, even if they were a nonprofit, it still costs money to do the deed. So yeah, we'd still pay for it.

Nonprofit doesn't mean they do things for free.

9

u/exipheas 8d ago

You buy bags of coal for what? A home furnace or something?

63

u/vandergale 8d ago

Christmas

1

u/Was_It_The_Dave 8d ago

I accidentally on purpose taught my teen boy a lesson with this. He was big mad. Don't shoplift at YOUR CO-OP PLACEMENT WE HELPED YOU GET THEN!!!

7

u/dirtycheezit 8d ago

Old school blacksmithing?

17

u/exipheas 8d ago

If they don't answer I have assume they think this is a charcoal mine.

13

u/dirtycheezit 8d ago

"charcoal mine" lmao. I think there's an extremely high likelihood your assumption is correct

1

u/HeyLittleTrain 8d ago

Not sure about elsewhere but in UK/Ireland coal is extremely common for home heating.

1

u/exipheas 8d ago

Yea but if you are doing that you probably aren't buying a "bag" at a time. The dude was thinking this was charcoal for the BBQ.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/HeyLittleTrain 8d ago

To burn in the fireplace

0

u/Neutronpulse 8d ago

Do you not own a grill?

16

u/Tall_olive 8d ago

I don't know about you, but I use charcoal(which is a man made product derived from wood) in my grill.

5

u/Neutronpulse 8d ago

Fair enough. I didn't put much thought into that.

0

u/tepsic7 8d ago edited 6d ago

For barbecue, I use in my grill.

Edit: My bad, I confused charcoal with coal. At least now I got to read up on the diffrence between them.

8

u/Tall_olive 8d ago

You sure you don't mean charcoal? Which is entirely different and man made.

9

u/ItsWillJohnson 8d ago

please do not eat foods cooked over burning coal. or be near burning coal. don't burn coal to begin with really.

3

u/JasonGD1982 8d ago

Lol. Did he confuse charcoal with coal? Surely he isn't cooking hotdogs and hamburgers over a coal grill 🤣🤣🤣

2

u/tepsic7 6d ago

Yup, my bad. I confused charcoal with coal.

At least now I got to read up on the diffrence between them.

7

u/ChornWork2 8d ago

charcoal for bbq is made from wood (cooked without oxygen so chars), not derived from mined coal.

5

u/Chess42 8d ago

Who tf uses coal in a grill?? Use charcoal like a normal person!

2

u/ayriuss 8d ago

That's crazy. Ive never even seen coal in real life. Just charcoal. Its been illegal to burn here since before I was born.

2

u/psysxet 8d ago

charcoal, not coalcoal, right?

1

u/window-sil 8d ago

I mean in this clip we probably saw like ~$10 worth of coal mined. Two people paid for 90 seconds of work to generate $10 worth of coal aint bad.

1

u/Longjumping_Act_9204 8d ago

I got a bag of coal for christmas once.

1

u/Traveller7142 8d ago

What store sells bags of coal?

1

u/BetterCranberry7602 8d ago

Tractor supply

1

u/USAFmuzzlephucker 8d ago

Some people do still burn it at home. Several homes in my little town still burn coal for heat. It's a strangely welcome smell in the fall.

1

u/777777thats7sevens 8d ago

My hardware store does

0

u/fynn34 8d ago

I just had a conversation with ChatGPT about it, there’s different types of coal, some of which are worth more (up to 2-4X for steel types and stuff) and ultimately, it’s fairly compact so a cubic meter is about 1.1-1.5 metric tonnes, and in that perspective, a single miner could get 5-20 tonnes per day, which even factoring transportation could still be slightly profitable. If you are using open mines and heavy mining equipment you can get many many tonnes out at once

1

u/rickane58 8d ago

"I just had a conversation with ChatGPT about it" is such a totally normal and human way to say it.

1

u/fynn34 5d ago

Are you implying a bot would chat with ChatGPT? How would you say it?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Todespudel 8d ago

It's a lot when you factor in the high density. the big chunks they got out of the wall with their pneumatic drills probably weighed several hundred kilos each.

1

u/Roflkopt3r 8d ago

True, from what I could find it seems that the density of anthracite (very pure mined coal) is in the range of 1.3-1.8 g/cm3 (so about 1.5 kg per L, or 1500 kg per m3). They could definitely drill off a few hundred kg at a time when they encounter veins of this size.

1

u/Schwa4aa 8d ago

Depends if it’s an American ton… weights 204.6 pounds less than a metric ton

2

u/Flaky_Guitar9018 8d ago

I don't use clown units

2

u/Schwa4aa 8d ago

Nor do I, but as their neighbour, I need to be wary of the difference

1

u/Cultural_Dust 8d ago

I'm sure you're "money shot" is worth more. It's just real hard to gather a ton.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/mitch_medburger 8d ago

At least 3.50.

13

u/cmdr_solaris_titan 8d ago

That damn loch nes monsta gonna come take it!

4

u/CaptinEmergency 8d ago

Tree fiddy

2

u/drbastille 8d ago

I gave em a dolla

2

u/BaconCheeseBurger 8d ago

Literally pennies.

2

u/TinUser 8d ago

A naughty year if you're a kid

1

u/touchmybonushole 8d ago

I got a tour of the Falkirk mine in North Dakota, it’s an open hole and they use house sized dump trucks to move over burden (everything above the vein of coal), all the equipment is preposterously massive and expensive. The first vein is 60 feet below the surface, they reclaim all the land and return it to the farmers as they move along. They operate 24 hours a day 365 days a year and have been open since 1978 with another ~60 years or something crazy before they expect to run out of material. All their shovels and some of their larger hoes are electric, everything else is diesel.

So how much is that amount of coal worth? Not much but collectively it justifies operating and maintaining all that equipment none stop in North Dakota and they don’t even power that big of an area.

Side note: before our tour I was watching these massive transport truck move across the horizon and they’re so big they look much closer to you and like toys, it was a very interesting experience.

1

u/G_DIZZLE_FO_SHIZZLE 8d ago

Bout three fiddy

1

u/Bucket_of_Guts 8d ago

Tree fiddy

1

u/Champagne_of_piss 8d ago

Very cheap. You could afford several tons but you could not afford the infrastructure to store it or efficiently convert it into electricity.

1

u/Just_Learned_2_Dance 8d ago

Not an expert but have some experience with coal. I’m guessing about tree fiddy

1

u/reality72 8d ago

bout tree fiddy

1

u/EatSoupFromMyGoatse 8d ago

You haul 16 tons, and what do you get?

Another day older and deeper in debt.

1

u/grimpaaj 7d ago

Is coal like fossil fuels or it's just carbon rock and not organic

3

u/[deleted] 8d ago

Do you know what the matte colored rock is? Is it just shale and does it depend on location what kind of rock is around it?

1

u/Exciting-Type-907 8d ago

What’s the matte rock around it?

2

u/Compost-Mentis 8d ago

and how do you separate that part out later on?

2

u/insomnimax_99 8d ago edited 8d ago

The rock around it is shale.

Coal floats, whereas the vast majority of impurities like rock do not, so they run the coal through water and get rid of the impurities that sink to the bottom.

Downside of this is that it results in lots of toxic contaminated water that has to be disposed of carefully, which doesn’t always happen because the proper disposal methods are expensive.

1

u/Voyeurdolls 8d ago

How do i know where to dig

1

u/Deep-Confusion-5472 8d ago

What’s the other?

1

u/Op1am 8d ago

Playing Minecraft with the kids taught me this!

1

u/That_Scientist_8730 8d ago

And the grey part is slate?

1

u/iloveinspire 4d ago

In Poland we call it Black Gold