r/WTF 9d ago

One little mistake can have grave consequences...

12.6k Upvotes

522 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

304

u/Zarda_Shelton 8d ago

So the smoke calms them by making them feel the urge to pack up and run away from death? Am I reading that right?

Maybe me and bees just think differently, but when I need to flee something that tends to be the opposite of calming.

316

u/Senocs 8d ago

I think this explanation is more correct:

When bees sense danger, they release an alarm pheromone called isopentyl acetate from a gland near their stingers. This chemical wafts through the air and alerts other bees to be ready to attack. Smoking a beehive masks this pheromone, allowing the beekeeper to safely perform a hive inspection.

https://www.buddhabeeapiary.com/blog/why-do-beekeepers-use-smoke

That's why they attack as soon as the smoke clears

128

u/Tactical_Moonstone 8d ago

isopentyl acetate

It's also a common compound released by fruit and fermented drinks, which is why there is a common wisdom saying that you should not go near a beehive if you have eaten or handled a banana recently.

127

u/Dripz167 8d ago

Common!? That’s the first time I heard of this! Thank you 🙏

61

u/Zarda_Shelton 8d ago

Yep, very common. Almost as common as 'don't take a griddle to a haystack'.

7

u/LameBMX 8d ago

I did that once, never again.

3

u/JCoxRocks 7d ago

Super bizarre to experience the first time handling a hive. Smells like banana flavored runts and then suddenly the little girls are bouncing off your face screen

4

u/Triscuitador 7d ago

interesting, i'm familiar with isoamyl acetate as a yeast byproduct, and it also smells like bananas

1

u/Pure-Community-8415 6d ago

My grandpa always bought refrigerated Bud Light cases and kept them in a closet and then re-refrigerated them and it always tasted or smelled like bananas. I guess that explains why… never would I have thought this

1

u/SexIsBetterOutdoors 7d ago

I have fed my bees overripe bananas several times before and have never noticed any change in behavior.

2

u/personalcheesecake 8d ago

Ah so that's why they immediately started on him.

2

u/mrcookieeater 7d ago

You are both correct. Although I'm specifically referring to Apis Mellifera aka the European/Western honey bee, smoke masks the angry banana smells and makes them want to gorge on honey and ignore you. Just a couple puffs can buy you around 20 minutes to work with the hive in my experience. I've had bees that were so gentle I didn't need smoke or protective gear and bees that were so cantankerous that it was like smoke never existed. Source-am beekeeper.

2

u/duffkitty 8d ago

Hold my banana daiquiri, I'm going in.

1

u/Laurpud 8d ago

That's so interesting, thank you!

30

u/A_ChadwickButMore 8d ago

It also partially covers up the alarm/attack pheromone scent. Its the same chemical as artificial banana (isopropyl acetate) and can actually be smelled by humans who done a fuck up in the hive. Just having banana candies before hive time increases your odds of getting stung

15

u/Evla03 8d ago

It's different when they don't care about themselves and just the hive, better to be calm and try to save as much as possible compared to fleeing and just dying because you need your hive

3

u/Pornfest 8d ago

There’s also the use of tobacco/nicotine to smoke bees, where nicotine is a strong neuroactive chemical. Anyone who’s smoked a cigarette too fast knows what too much nicotine feels like.

2

u/Simple_Rooster3 8d ago

Dang it I understood it the same

2

u/kurotech 6d ago

Think of it like a fire drill at a school everyone calmly gathers together and calmly walks out otherwise you cause a trample

2

u/Drone30389 8d ago
  • Facing an intruder: hive goes into fight mode.

  • Facing fire: hive goes into pack up and leave mode.

Fight mode would be very counterproductive against a fire.

3

u/Zarda_Shelton 8d ago

Flee mode is not a calm mode