r/science Professor | Medicine Jan 06 '25

Health After the US overturned Roe v Wade, permanent contraception surged among young adults living in states likely to ban abortion, new research found. Compared to May 2022, August 2022 saw 95% more vasectomies and 70% more tubal sterilizations performed on people between the ages of 19 and 26.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jan/06/permanent-contraception-abortion-roe-v-wade
22.3k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

43

u/baes__theorem Jan 07 '25

that’s great for sure, but probably not when you were 19-26, right?

also the case is different for people with uteruses – tubal ligations aren’t even allowed in lots of places if you’re under 30 and childless, let alone covered by insurance. it’s also a more complex and invasive procedure, and thus more expensive ¯_(ツ)_/¯

40

u/Emotional-Cash5378 Jan 07 '25

It took me 3 months of calling various doctors & clinics until I found one that would perform my tubal. I even tried fibbing by telling them I had been pregnant twice when they asked if I’d had children but they either then asked if I had carried them to term (I hadn’t) or said their threshold for the procedure on someone younger than 30 was 3 living children. It was infuriating!

30

u/Killbot_Wants_Hug Jan 07 '25

That really sucks. I told this story in this thread elsewhere, but you might think it's kind of funny.

A friend of mine growing up wanted to get her tubes tied. She was in her early 20's. The doctor told her no because she was too young and she might change her mind.

She told the doctor that if she got pregnant she'd put the baby in a blender and pour it through their mail slot.

The doctor decided she wasn't mother material after all and scheduled the operation.

To be fair to the doctor, I think a lot of people do change their mind. But I think it's also the patient's decision and as long as they're informed about the procedure and if it's reversible or not, than that's really all there should be to it.

35

u/Pineapple_Herder Jan 07 '25

I don't know if enough people regret it to validate some of the insulting arguments made by doctors. My friend got her tubes tied and they asked her what her husband thought. She didn't have a husband. They asked about her future husband and she was like "Why would I marry him if we don't agree on something as fundamental as children?"

She ended up finding a different doctor, but oh boy do I remember the ranting phone call after that appointment. She was livid.

2

u/neurodiverseotter Jan 08 '25

Yeah, when a hypothetical mans opinion over a womans body is more important than her own choice. This must be the time where "White men are the most discriminated group of all"

1

u/Pineapple_Herder Jan 09 '25

I understand why a doctor would ask, if the patient is married or in a long term relationship, have you discussed this with your partner? Because it does affect more than just the patient, and could be a reasonable line of questions that could unveil larger issues like domestic violence etc. Or uncover that the patient is making a permanent decision for temporary issues.

But to have a patient whose only risk is age be required to jump through so many hoops and grilled seems discriminatory not reasonable.

16

u/KnownCar9524 Jan 07 '25

3 kids? That’s ridiculous

22

u/LoosePhone1 Jan 07 '25

My SO just got a vasectomy within that age range. It was mostly covered by insurance but still expensive!

5

u/Cautious-Progress876 Jan 07 '25

Mine was $500 out of pocket without insurance. How much was your SO’s?

1

u/LoosePhone1 Jan 10 '25

It was around 1k but he had it done at a hospital under anesthesia so that probably made it cost more than usual

1

u/Doctor_Philgood Jan 07 '25

Mine covered 90 percent. All said and done, it was around 90 bucks. But this is some expensive insurance and should not be considered the norm.

But every penny is worth it.

2

u/Cautious-Progress876 Jan 07 '25

I view mine as worth it. I had a kid young due to being stupid and reckless, and wanted to make sure that never happened again. Plus my current SO doesn’t want children so me being fixed takes a lot of worry/risk away.

1

u/Killbot_Wants_Hug Jan 07 '25

I would assume health insurance would happily pay for sterilization (especially if women).

Birthing is super expensive and a sterilization could save an insurance company from paying out multiple births.

I was on a high deductible plan when my wife got married. I wasn't expecting for her to get pregnant so fast (I sort of assumed/hoped I was sterile) so I didn't have time to change it after getting married.

I'm not sure how much the birthing procedure cost, but I know I had to pay my full $10,000 deductible, so it's pretty expensive.

A sterilization procedure is a drop in the bucket compared to that. So I would guess most insurance plans would cover it as it's just the best way to make money, which is their main goal. The exception probably being if the plan was paid for by a religious organization that specifically didn't want those services provided.