I don't know if I've seen a rise in popularity of this question lately. But the subreddits I dwell in are full of people asking to rate their art.
I can't really blame them, because societal conventions imply that art can be rated one to ten. You're graded for it in school, you're given a numerical value for your effort. Then if there's a movie you want to see or somethething, metacritic does the same thing, more or less.
Chief, I'm tired. You can't rate art like that. If you ask people to give you a number, it's arbitrary.
It tells you nothing. Unless the commenter comes in and tells you their whole standardised grading scheme and how weighted those different criteria are, it does nothing to help you. Nooothingggg. Stahhhhp it.
Everyone values different things yes? If your colour selection is harmonious then someone who loves colour will come in with their arbitrary score and rate it so. If I think the perspective is wonky and don't care about colour then I will value it differently. Numbers. Mean. Nothing.
Please. My proposed solution is to ask for nuanced feedback if you want it. If you've been working the perspective then ask how's my perspective. You been studying hand bones? I don't doubt some hand bone experts are out there to come in to help you. Phalanges and shit bro.
So yes. I make post this in my own selfish desire to stop seeing this annoying question man. Stop it! Get help! (Full transparency, I am referencing a meme when I say that.)