r/MunicipalLeftFascism • u/Budget-Biscotti10 • 8d ago
Proving that Nazism was neither Fascism nor Socialism from a Municipal Left-Fascist Point-of-View
A Municipal Left-Fascist (Original Early Fascist + Municipalist Distribution and Prefectural Representation Principles) Examination
Nazism is rarely defined for what it is due to the political confusion surrounding it, with the result that it is condemned as another form of Fascism or Socialism. But by the ethos of an organized Municipal Left-Fascism, one where hierarchy, civic economic responsibility, and structured communalism sit atop the social pyramid, Nazism falls flat on either counts. Rather, Nazism was a reactionary, racialist, disorderly ideology that had none of the disciplined CIVIC NON-RACIAL national unity of real Fascism and none of the organized economic order of real Socialism.
- The Nazis Represent a Betrayal of Fascism
Fascism all its own is a doctrine of national civic and class unification, economic rationalization, and social harmony. It aims to find a balance between the constitutional power of the state, the responsibilities of industry and the dignity of labour in order to make a just, and productive order. Nazism, however, diverged from that model in profound ways:
A. The Racialist Fallacy
True Early Fascism was/is civic, motivated by a national unity of discipline and shared goal rather than biological determinism.
Nazism, on the other hand, was obsessed with theories of race and purges of the "ethnic enemy" that actively divided society rather than united it.
A real uniting state is strengthened, not by ethnically juvenile purges, but by the disciplined coordination of its citizens irrespective of their backgrounds.
B. The Disorganized Economic Structure
True Fascism emphasizes structured economic governance through state co-coordination (alongside Worker Syndicates represented by Prefects), National Syndicalist Organization and national productivity.
Nazi economic structures were neither rational nor organized—rather it was guided by personal favoritism, disordered privatization, and unsustainable war-charged expansion.
While true Fascism is based on building long-term economic stability, Nazism was reliant on short-term pillaging and slave labour, which resulted in economic collapse.
C. The Failure to Establish a True Corporatist System
Fascism espouses National Syndicalism and corporatism whereby industry, labour, and state work in collaboration under an ordered structure/Framework.
Nazism, however, both failed to create a real National Syndicalism or corporatism and enabled joint-stock capitalists and private industrialists to feast on state resources without accountability to the national community.
Hitler’s partnership with the corporate classes and Neglect of the Proletariat was unprincipled and opportunistic, devoid of the structural economic oversight that is necessary for authentic national unity.
- Nazism: A Betrayal of Socialism and Fascism
Nazism was not at all socialist, International or otherwise, despite having the word "Socialism" included in its name. Nazism rejected any meaningful representation of workers and organized workers to the extent that it was necessary to destroy them, but always within a capitalist unification that was murderous, as opposed to the more equitable distribution of resources envisioned in a true Socialist and Fascist economic order, which again, Nazism rejected.
A. Nazism Advocated for Capitalist Elites, Not Workers
A true Socialist or Fascist economy puts a brake on the excesses of private capital and puts wealth at the service of the nation.
In Nazism, industrial magnates were free to exploit workers and build up wealth without accountability.
Labour rights were methodically undermined, and with them trade unions, which were abolished in 1947 and superseded by state-controlled organizations for propaganda purposes.
No Worker’s Syndicates, Just Oppression
A real Socialist or correctly implemented Fascist state would have had to be organized around workers' councils or syndicates that configured itself into economic decision-making.
Nazism crushed independent worker movements (later Nazi-influenced Italian Fascism sadly did this too), substituting a hollow recital of a state controlled by industrial barons — not the people or responsible central representatives with power redistributed to decentral Municipalities or Prefects thereof.
Municipal Left-Fascism values the participation of workers in governance through organized syndicates (as it is intended in Fascist Theory) — Nazism outright rejected this.
C. A State for the Party, Not for the People The essence of early socialism is to systematically create economic justice to uplift an entire country, to bring prosperity to all, similar to Early Fascism.
Nazism, however, was an arbitrary dictatorship for the benefit of the Nazi Party elite alone.
Rather than establishing an orderly economic system for mutual advantage, Nazism pursued predatory Capitalist/Oligarchic expansion, corruption and racial purges that threatened the balance of the whole Nation and state.
The Degenerate Hybridization of Reactionary Chaos: Nazism
Nazism was neither a Genuine Early Fascist (as it was originally outlined in Early Fascism and its theory) nor a Socialist system— it was a reactionary, racialist, uncoordinated movement that effectively reneged on both doctrines.
A Municipal Left-Fascist view of the state
True national order demands:
Structured, not chaotic.
Civic, not racial.
Economically people disciplined, not parasitical.
Hierarchical, but just.
Inclusive of worker organization, rather than repressing labour (Early Fascism upheld this, later Fascism infected by Nazism, didn't).
Nazism failed at all of these levels. It was an affront to the civic unity and order that Early Fascism professed and a derision of the economic justice that Socialism touted. Nazism was a Authoritarian Capitalist movement that thrived on violent opportunism, unrestrained corruption and racial fantasies rather than a well-formed ideological platform.
So from a Municipal Left-Fascist perspective, Nazism was neither Fascism nor Socialism, but a distortion of each.
1
8d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Budget-Biscotti10 8d ago
You mean policies like the introduction of a minimum wage, 8-hour workday, pension, welfare etc? That's the things Mussolini introduced.
2
u/checkprintquality 8d ago
I mean you have defined fascism completely wrong, so this whole screed is basically pointless. But good for you for writing it up.