Spoilers for season 1 and Hot Fuzz

I was rewatching the show (literally watching episode 3/4 right now as I write this), the plot is literally the same as Hot Fuzz. Newcomer arrives in a small town nobody as ever heard of and is seemingly perfect upon first glance, finds things a little off, discovers there is something a foot in the town with a group of villains plotting to change everything for the greater good, then the newcomer recruits some locals, including high schoolers, to take down the villains in a final action set piece and one of the villains is defeated via car and animal, but Icicle got the lamer defeat since no swan. Also the GREAT BIG BUSHY BEARDS with Nick's predacessor and Sir Justin. These are just some of the similarities I spotted while watching, and it is hilarious to me.

… how miserable and depressing Season 2 is. My God. It’s great, don’t get me wrong - but Season 1 was such happy-go-lucky-superhero fun with the right amount of darkness. It’s my comfort show. Then, Season 2 turns it SO UP with the darkness, legitimately torturing all the main characters episode after episode.

Once again, I’m not saying it’s a bad season - but the switch in tone is pretty jarring.

Anyone else notice this when watching?

This is the first episode I wrote for a season as well as a poster concept, just ignore the watermark at the bottom and mentally crop it out. Hope you enjoy

It was only $63 total. Ive been meaning to buy it cuz i already have Titans, now im in forever possession of my favorite show. I cant go into detail regarding how much this show inspires me creatively. Such a wonderful show. Ill always promote this show whenever i have the chance.

Fan Expo Chicago 2022. Me and one of my best pals met Brec. She also signed my Stars and S.T.R.I.P.E. #1. I had Geoff Johns sign it later that same day.

Brand new to Stargirl, and the whole justice society of America thing as a whole. In the middle of episode 3, and Pat has taken her to the JSOA headquarters and there's a whole owl there?? Why isn't it being fed and taken care of? By what they talked about I'm assuming maybe some of her school friends will be joining. Please tell me someone takes that poor owl and cares for it? Im feeling so bad for it being locked up there all alone :(

First book signed by Geoff., Alex & Brec.

Second book has Geoff, Brec, John Wesley Shipp and Joel McHale. Wish I could get some of the others from the show.

She's a teenage girl who's had to adjust to moving away from her old state and friends, cuz her mom married a nice, stable man she loves. Courtney is a major daddy's girl even tho her dad hasn't been in her life since she was like 4 years-old. Her mom straight up told her that her dad was a dead beat who only saw them once a year, but she somehow connects that to him really being Starman. How she got to that conclusion is beyond me. If that's true, wouldn't she think that's its incredibly weird that Starman's sidekick is now MARRIED to Starman's wife/Courtney's mom??? She's incredibly headstrong, and always brushes off Pat's advice and instructions when he's completely in the right. And he just lets her do whatever she wants even though she could easily get killed. When she forces Pat to fight Icicle with her, Joey ends up getting killed in the midst of it. It doesn't immediately dawn on her that she basically got Joey killed because she decided to rush into an OBVIOUS trap that she had no reason to go into. Icicle didn't even threaten her family like brainwave did, she could've just ignored it. I know it's the typical brash superhero teenager, but Courtney refuses to learn anything so far. I've only started watching so I hope she gets better writing, but am I overreacting?

Literally pulls a Dr Schultz on the guard

Cyclone - Courtney’s best friend in the JSA should've been in the show anyway but probably would've been blocked because Black Adam (probably why Hawkman and Dr Fate were just in photographs and not in person)

Sand/Damage - Both were mentioned to be members in the epilogue and both were the only ones who didn't show up. Plus Sand was mentioned in the Infinity Inc two-parter so it would be nice to see him show up

Starman - Have a storyline where the grandson of the original Starman shows up and sees what became of the staff. Maybe have him want it back but maybe that feels like a repeat of Season 3

Crimson Avenger - We saw the original Crimson Avenger in the Seven Soldiers of Victory photo so to see the more modern version show up with the Spirit of Vegeance and have her try to take vengeance on Artemis for killing Icicle or Pat for killing the Ultra Humanite or something like that

Magog - This one is purely because I think he's interesting. It would be nice to see him show up but I wouldn't complain if he didn't

The og Fiddler - While he is in the show, he cameos once or twice and then gets mentioned and a few times. He could've been out for vengeance because of his wife and son being dead. It could even be tied to Crimson Avenger with them teaming up to get vengeance

What characters would you have liked to show up?

I was wondering this for a while now: why was ARGUS not in the show?

In every Earth, Amanda Waller knows more about people then they do about themselves. Remember in S1 when Pat showed a photo of him being part of the 7 Soldiers? He said that-> they saved the whole world once & the whole country twice (just them). No way ARGUSA doesn't go after that after that. Plus the 7 Soldiers would've been world famous like The Avengers. I think it would've been fun to have Waller go after Courtney and have her do a mission for her. I'm sure Pat has met her before. I'm sure Cindy was being spied on.

Is this show gonna be worth it? Is it a valuable watch for the rest of the arrowverse? How does it rank compared to the rest of the shows?

Me personally, I think the coach that had the "accident" with the ride on lawnmower that Crusher and Paula mentioned in season one episode six, actually was an accident and not a murder. I think they planned to kill him, but the coach legitimately did have an accident and everyone just assumed they did it, so they just went along with it. Is this fully in character with the Crocks? Probably not, but the idea of them going to visit the coach to kill him and then finding him already dead but Jordan wasn't far behind and found the scene and just assumed the Crocks did it and them just going along with it because it would make them seem weak to have their target be taken down entirely by accident is just too entertaining for me not to think it’s true. So what about you, you got any funny headcannons?

Maybe it’s just me. But I don’t care for Beth at all. She has no point. She can’t do much. All she has is the goggles. Such a useless and pointless character

I’m rewatching the show and I remembered how much I hated beth with a passion because she was never supposed to get the googles she technically forced herself in the group and all that could be excused if she would have been able to do something in every fight scene in the show except the last season she got her ass handed to her and she never actually was useful they kinda used her as a token black character for god sake she doesn’t even get her own episode it’s bundled with Rick for the first two seasons and when she finally does get a combat mode on her googles (that one I blame pat bc he should have told her) we see two fights of her barely using it I think they should have replaced her with someone else or better yet never had her at all

Maria Montez or Matt Harris?

While I notice a trend of mostly girls getting the superpowers, I don't mind it at all, probably 'cause the show is made/focused for a female audience and stuff. I actually favor it being mostly girls, because every guy introduced so far seems to be a bone head with a short temper.

There are many illogical moments in the show, that I try to look past and whatnot, however this one episode, with the introduction of the new green lantern pissed me off, I had to rant.

What happened to the Green Lantern ring choosing the most worthy, just and person with the most will power? What's up with this nepotism promotion? She's his daughter, so she get's the ring automatically? That's trash! Especially after the show telling us in the previous season, with Stargirl, that anyone can be chosen.

Especially the way she broke into their home and claimed that the lantern belonged to her father, so she gets to have it.