r/politics • u/Mason_Miami • 1d ago

Conservative group claims Trump's tariffs illegally usurp powers of Congress

https://lawandcrime.com/high-profile/this-unlawful-impost-must-fall-conservative-group-sues-trump-claiming-tariffs-are-unconstitutional-exercise-of-legislative-power/
17.0k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

351 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/pigfoot 23h ago

If you look at their litigation history, they’ve consistently chosen cases that center around Executive overreach.

You may not like the particular remedies that they developed or from this perspective (I don’t), but it seems fairly consistent.

That’s the thing about balance of powers - it needs to be consistent regardless of the political flavor of the Executive. This case is representative of the kind of battles they pick, for better or worse.

18

u/TheMadBug 22h ago

Genuine question - did this same conservative group have litigation when Trump used his executive overreach to -

Kidnap people to prison without judicial oversight?

Fire investigator generals without cause?

Chaotically slash funding / employment allocated by congress?

Give excessive amounts of top secret information to a private citizen?

Completely replace boards of what were meant to be independent organisations?

Violate the hatch act by having a car commercial on the White House lawn?

Or do they only litigate when the stock market is in danger? And presumably when interest payments on student loans are forgiven?

10

u/pigfoot 22h ago

No. But I said that they were consistent not exhaustive. You can read a list of the cases they brought to the Supreme Court on Wikipedia.

And yeah, I think they suck too.

8

u/TheMadBug 21h ago

Ugh I just checked their Wikipedia. Should have known they were a Koch group.

I could argue pedantically with you if they’re consistent or not - but no point as we both agree they suck.