r/skeptic 25d ago

đŸ’© Misinformation Neuroscientist podcaster with 20+ hours of ADHD content discovers it MIGHT be genetic "but there are too many variables to separate"!!!

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

204 comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/PatchyWhiskers 25d ago

My kid has ADHD, my husband has ADHD, and his family on the paternal side are all diagnosed or just act like they have ADHD. Family events are interesting.

21

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted]

6

u/DemonicAltruism 25d ago

both of my parents show signs of it... My Dad is especially inattentive and loses track of time very easily. He forgets things mid sentence and is very easy to drive off track into a completely different topic...

He refuses to get diagnosed because of asshats like this Huberman telling him all he needs is some vitamins and a "healthy diet" (he HATES veggies btw... Go figure...) he's subscribed to like, 4 different vitamin regimen subscription services and buys directly from advocate (a MLM) on a regular basis... He's part of the reason I've gone down the skeptic rabbit hole lol...

My mom is just really stubborn and also forgets things easily... However both my half siblings are diagnosed ASD so... Idk, maybe a double whammy for me over here... (For clarity, only have an ADHD diagnosis, not a co-morbidity with ASD)

3

u/Appropriate-Food1757 25d ago

Me too. Then I thought about my Dad and brother!

11

u/SocDemGenZGaytheist 25d ago

damn that's crazy it's almost like

ADHD is
 1st Author Year
74% heritable Faraone 2019
75% heritable Schachar 2014
80% heritable Chang 2013
76% heritable Rommelse 2010
76% heritable Faraone 2004

5

u/littlelupie 24d ago

I have ADHD, my kid has ADHD, my dad and sister both have ADHD. My poor mother and partner don't and they are saints for putting up with us lol 

-18

u/BioMed-R 25d ago

Yuge overdiagnosis.

I couldn’t believe in a diagnosis that some assign to double digit numbers of the population.

9

u/ZZ9ZA 25d ago

So you take the position that Asthma and Diabetes’s don’t exist?

0

u/BioMed-R 24d ago

These are only barely in the double digits
 there are doctors who say ADHD affects 50% of the population and the probability that someone’s whole kin is affected is absurd. That’s overdiagnosis.

10

u/SocDemGenZGaytheist 25d ago

I couldn’t believe in a diagnosis that some assign to double digit numbers of the population

how about “obese” (~42%) or “nearsighted” (~30%)

0

u/BioMed-R 24d ago

Those statistics are American, not global. That’s cherry-picking.

It’s a behavioral diagnosis – normal range behavior pathologized.

2

u/Essekker 24d ago

Hold up, am I understanding your comment right; Too many people supposedly have it, therefore you don't believe in the diagnosis in the first place?

1

u/BioMed-R 24d ago

It’s normal range behavior. A comparable problem would “overweight” individuals according to BMI have better health.