Seems like I finally found it! After using everything, including Blue Chips, I started using the green tortexes, learned about how a thicker pick can impact playing, gave the new reissue Adamas Graphite picks a try (which are essentially plastic with barely any graphite compared to originals Jerry played), those were great but slippery, even with Picker’s Grip applied, went back to green tortexes, cuz that material has amazing grip, then was recommended the thickest Gator Grips, pick nirvanna. The black Gator Grips have the best of both worlds, the thickness and control of the Adamas, and the feel of Tortex, in a slightly smaller shape, amazing picks. Two mm is the way with Gator’s.