r/MonsterHunter Mar 03 '25

MH Wilds Guys this is crazy

Post image
6.2k Upvotes

914 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

13

u/NamasteWager Mar 03 '25

I don't know, do you think it can out sell Street Fighter 6? /s

But it had to be, the only real competitor is Resident Evil i think. Capcom is such a solid developer right now, so many of their IPs, big and small, are amazing

The thing I love is that MH was only around 60gb to install. I am so sick of 100+gb games on my hard drive that don't feel justified. I don't play, but heard COD was like 120gb or something and that just feels like they didn't clean or optimize anything

6

u/Ok_Fox_1120 Mar 03 '25

Solid developer put out two unoptimized messes in the last year

2

u/NamasteWager Mar 03 '25

I know one is Wilds but what was the other one?

My computer is a potato so the game would run bad either way for me, so I don't know a difference lol

5

u/RadiantJustice Mar 03 '25

Dragon's Dogma 2

1

u/NamasteWager Mar 03 '25

Oooh i didn't play thay one, but i do recall now hearing stuff about the performance being rough, thank you for clarity!

2

u/Icandothemove Mar 03 '25

They both use the same engine and both are heavily cpu bottlenecked.

Lot of people with 4070s but 8 year old CPUs getting shocked Pikachu faces they can't run a brand new game on ultra just because they have a relatively modern GPU.

2

u/sreiches Mar 04 '25

Notably, even on a 4090/7800X3D combo, I’m hitting that CPU bottleneck. I’d be interested to know if the 9800X3D’s faster clocks help with that, or if the issue is thread count.

1

u/Icandothemove Mar 04 '25

That is interesting. I have a 14900k (under volted for stability) and I've been planning on replacing it with a 9800 so I'd be curious about that too.

I haven't had any issues though.

2

u/sreiches Mar 04 '25

Yeah, I wouldn’t say I’ve had issues, but it’s interesting that DLSS doesn’t really impact my frame rate much. Since that uses a lower actual render resolution, it typically offsets more of the load onto the CPU.

With DLSS on, my GPU utilization goes down, but my frame rate is mostly unaffected.

I remember this being a known “issue” with the most recent Microsoft Flight Simulator, as well. It can tank performance on a 7800X3D or 9800X3D regardless of GPU because it’s so heavily multithreaded.

2

u/Hezik Mar 03 '25

Hes probably talking about Dragons Dogma 2

2

u/NamasteWager Mar 03 '25

Ah didn't play that one, but it having rough reviews due to performance is ringing a bell. Thank you for clarifying!

0

u/Ok_Fox_1120 Mar 03 '25

Yeah sorry was knocking some stuff out, ty reddit was indeed referring to dd2

0

u/jaggedcanyon69 Mar 03 '25

Solid developers have bad years. Big whoop.

0

u/Andrea_Notte90 Mar 03 '25

to be fair I don't think it was the fault of the devs (as most times) but just higher ups rushing, the devs probably knew that REngine is not for open world and they are working on the next iteration that ks better for open worlds

-11

u/lickme920 Mar 03 '25

Idk they both work great on my PS5. Maybe it's your system? "PC Master Race" tears taste amazing!

6

u/Calm-Internet-8983 Mar 03 '25

A millenia ago, bait was still believable.

2

u/Ok_Fox_1120 Mar 03 '25

Man you console boys don't even know you're being taken advantage of, it's genuinely sad to think about.

0

u/Six6Sins Mar 03 '25

Taken advantage of?

I bought a PS5 specifically for Wilds. It was literally the cheapest option available to play the game. Even building a rig on sale by picking parts myself would have been more expensive than the base PS5 after the Pro came out.

500USD for the console. Show me a five-hundred dollar PC rig that can run Wilds as well as base PS5 right now. I'll wait.

2

u/903tex Mar 03 '25

What do you mean? You can easily build a PC to run wilds with specs greater than PS5 for 500. Majority of it would be used parts but It can be done.

0

u/Six6Sins Mar 03 '25

I could get a used PS5 for less than 500. You get to use pre-owned parts for price comparison then so do I.

2

u/903tex Mar 03 '25

But at the end of the day you still have something that not only a gaming machine but a actually computer but yes it can be done! You asked and I'm telling you it can be done.

0

u/Six6Sins Mar 03 '25

Ebay right now has base ps5 available for just under 400 USD. You're saying that you can build a PC rig at that price with used parts that can get comparable performance to a base PS5 on Monster Hunter Wilds? That's a tall order.

I can probably get base PS5 even cheaper than Ebay by digging at used game stores as well. What parts would you even pull for that rig?

And look, you don't have to sell me on the "but it's also a computer!" angle. That's not part of the comparison. I agree that PC is generally better, especially in the long run, because you can upgrade one part at a time instead of buying a new rig every time. That's not in question. The question is whether or not buying a console automatically means you are getting taken advantage of. Which I don't agree with.

2

u/903tex Mar 03 '25

Yes you can! I help my friend build one right at 500 and he's been playing wild with me. The thing is finding the deals. Area may vary

→ More replies (0)

2

u/main135s Mar 03 '25 edited Mar 03 '25

To build a full PC that's comparable to the PS5 Pro (technically, better, thanks to having more space for adequate cooling), it would cost ~$850 by MSRP. This is only $150 more than the PS5 Pro's current MSRP of $700. If we want to go super bare-bones (not recomended), we could get down to ~$700 if we make our own case or go caseless. Knock off ~$100 if we go for used/refurbished parts and sales.

Where the PC has the advantage is that the PC is inherently multifunctional, can be reasonably used to make money, and is modular and self-serviceable.

When the next generation of crap comes out, you don't need to buy another $700+ console to get the all-new performance, just buy the component that you need to upgrade and stick it in there. If something breaks, you can get a replacement part that day. So on and so forth.

Bottom line, so long as it's offered for the PC in the first place, you're able to try to see if a game works on your machine, if you can actually stretch your old components that much farther, rather than being beholden to what Sony allows your machine to download. Also, multiplayer without PS+; no need to pay another company to use the internet you already pay for.

1

u/Six6Sins Mar 03 '25

See, I agree with everything you said here. I just don't think it proves that the mere purchase of a console means you are being taken advantage of, which is what the person I replied to was saying.

1

u/kilian039 Mar 03 '25

yeah you right, cod aint doing shit, didnt even want to install the campaign but for some reason it did (?) then i only got multiplayer and zombies its still 187 gbs,

-2

u/NyMiggas Mar 03 '25

Just thank your lucky stars you didn't play dragons dogma 2