r/cookware Feb 28 '25

Is this nonstick pan / pot safe to use?

12 Upvotes

Hi all,

We have seen an increase in posts / arguments lately about the safety of nonstick cookware. Both in general, and also with varying degrees of wear / scratches. We wanted to make a sticky for reference on this subject.

From super mod u/Wololooo1996's amazing cookware guide, regarding nonstick cookware:

A general overview

There are many solid arguments online claiming that because modern PFAS Teflon is unreactive, it is "non-toxic" and therefore harmless to eat. While this is indeed a very convincing argument, there simply isn't enough scientific consensus for it to be considered definitive.

While we personally agree that a chunk of coating would likely pass right through the intestines, micro-particles accumulate in the human body in places where they aren’t supposed to. And while they may not directly cause harm when accumulated, they take up space that other human molecules were supposed to occupy, which can be problematic— especially if those molecules were supposed to perform a specific function.

We cannot explain these complex mechanisms in greater detail, as we are not doctors or molecular biologists. However, there are countless valid sources stating and/or explaining why PFAS, in certain amounts, is toxic to humans.

EEA - What are PFAS and how are they dangerous for my health?
WebMD - What is PFAS?
EPA - Our Current Understanding of Human Health and Environmental Risks of PFAS
The Guardian - What Are PFAS 'Forever Chemicals'? How Toxic Are They and How Do You Become Exposed?

Would something really bad, as indicated by these sources, happen from a single slightly scratched modern Teflon pan? Most likely not.

Is a modern nonstick Teflon pan virtually safe when used properly, and discarded before it gets scratched or inevitably worn down? Most likely. There are certainly far more toxic culinary hazards, like trans fats, reheated cooking oils, expired or otherwise oxidized vegetable oils, and most definitely the Standard American Diet (SAD). These are all, without a doubt, much worse than using a modern PFAS pan in pristine condition.

Is PFAS as a whole completely safe and harmless? Absolutely not. But it likely takes more than a single scratched modern nonstick pan to pose any substantial health risk. However, the risk is easily avoided by using uncoated cookware, like cast iron.

PFAs vs PFOAs

PFAS (Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances) and PFOA (Perfluorooctanoic Acid) are related, but different.

PFAS (Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances)

  • PFAS is a broad category that includes thousands of man-made chemicals.
  • These chemicals are known for their resistance to heat, water, and oil.
  • They are used in products like nonstick cookware, water-resistant clothing, food packaging, and firefighting foam.
  • PFAS persist in the environment and human body, earning them the nickname “forever chemicals.”

PFOA (Perfluorooctanoic Acid)

  • PFOA is a specific type of PFAS.
  • It was widely used in products like Teflon (nonstick cookware) and stain-resistant fabrics.
  • Due to health concerns, PFOA has been largely phased out in the U.S. but still lingers in the environment.
  • It has been linked to cancer, immune system issues, and other health risks.
Feature PFAS PFOA
Definition A large group of chemicals A specific chemical within PFAS
Uses Found in various industrial and consumer products Historically used in Teflon, firefighting foam, etc.
Regulation Some are being restricted due to health concerns Phased out in many countries but still present in the environment
Health Risks Potential risks vary by type Linked to cancer, immune issues, and developmental problems

PFOA is just one of many PFAS chemicals, but it is one of the most studied and concerning due to its health effects.

As well, from the World Health Organization:

Take with that what you will.

As a reminder, please keep these discussions civil and respectful. There is no need to attack one another. When it comes down to it, there is no clear-cut answer and definitive statement as to what is right and wrong. Everyone has their own risks they are willing to take, and it is up to each of us to do our own research and take action for what is best for our own health.


r/cookware Feb 25 '25

Announcement How to make a sufficient "Seeks specific kitchenware" post!

11 Upvotes

Introduction

We recieve endless repetitions of the same questions on this subreddit. This guide is to be referred to, whenever there is an obvious case of the user making a really insufficient low effort post, which could easily be avoided by reading this guide.

How to make a proper kitchenware post

If you want to buy and/or learn about kitchenware and especially stovetop cookware you have come to the right place! However, it will vastly improve the experience of everyone involved if a minimal effort is put into your post.

The more relavent information you include in your request the better for everyone including you, as you will get better advice in return.

It is completely allowed to request recommendations towards everything kitchen related like motar and pestele, mixers, blenders, ovens, tableware whatever, but if the post is about stovetop cookware then there is certain expectations that should be met.

Important stovetop cookware information inculdes:
The type of stove being used! Is it gas, induction, electric flattop, exposed coil stove?
The Budget! Self explanatory.
Location! are you from USA? Canada? EU? UK?

Other relevant information includes the weight of the cookware, and possible personal preferences like which country the cookware should be made in, and general specific information about what you desire of your next cookware.

An example of an improper post

Q: "Hello! I want the BEST frypan ever made, my budget is secret and I refuse to disclose my type of stove"

A: Well, congratulations! Here is an equally arbitrary recommendation: Solid silver cookware!

An example of a proper post

Q: "Hallo

I am moving away from home and need to buy two frypans.
My budget is around 120 (preferably USD or Euro) and I cook on a gasstove I have read the guide and considered this 11" (or 28cm) frypan named "OkayClad" but im not sure if its diswasher safe?
I have also read that nonstick is disposable, can someone also recommend a small pan that I can cook my eggs in that will last more than a few years?"

A post like this is almost guaranteed to get really good recommendations from people in the subreddit, even in unlikely cases where no helpful reply is made, I will personally help out with guidance :)

Be sure to check the Cookware Buying and Explanation Guide before asking for a new frypan: https://www.reddit.com/r/cookware/s/UQGGGjPXqg

Posts that very likely will be taken down

Posts requesting stovetop cookware recommendations that neither includes a budget, location or a stove type will be considered low effort and a big waste of everyones time and thereby likely be taken down.

Making a crappy "Seek Specific Kitchenware" type post but using a wrong tag, possibly in the attempt to have the post be considered something else, doesn't work at all!

If the post includes multible options to choose between, then it is possible to use the "Looking for Advice" flair/tag instead.

Posts that correctly or incorrectly uses the "Indentification" flair will likely not be taken down, especially not if containing a picture! In general only unredeemable junk, abvious spam and harmfull content gets taken down.

My post got taken down

There should most likely be an attached reason for why the post got taken down, if the post was not harmfull, then feel free to edit and improve your post and try again :)


r/cookware 3h ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Does this kind of saucepan/pot exist? and where can I find one?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Title says it all, I made this image out of a regular saucepan photo but I was wondering if a pot like this existed? Need to boil something long and cylindrical and it would do a great deal of good. Thanks


r/cookware 8h ago

Looking for Advice Is my friend's pan safe?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Hello r/cookware! This is my friend's daily frying pan. The food they cook most with this pan is eggs. I've never seen a pan so bad in my whole life.

I believe at one point in this pan's life it was non-stick, evident by the remnants of the coating around the edges. When nonstick coating chips it's time to replace the pan, but this is way past that. The condition is... dire.

They've had this pan for about 2+ years and they are unsure about the age of the pan. The metal is bare, no coating left. I assume it's constructed from aluminum since most nonstick pans are, but I can't be sure.

I am trying to convince them to replace their pan, but they won't part with it until the handle breaks off. The quality of cookware isn't something they ever thought about and I want to help. I believe they'd be better off with a stainless steel pan for quality of life, consistency, and safety.

I'm looking for more information about the metal they currently cook on every day and the possibility for metal leeching into their food.

Ultimatly: Is this pan still safe to use?


r/cookware 7h ago

New Acquisition Saks Fifth Demeyere Sale

3 Upvotes

Just wanted to make people aware of the sale on Saks Fith Ave with code HAPPY20SF. Everything from Demeyere is 20% off (other brands like Staub too but I’ve seen better deals on those even with the 20% off). If you have an Amex Platinum card, you can combine it for the $50 off credit. Not to mention an additional 2% from Rakuten if you use that (nothing to write home about but extra savings is extra savings). I was able to pick up my first Demeyere piece today that I have been eying for a while and I’m ecstatic. Picked up the 2.1qt Atlantis saucier (reg price $269.99) for $161 plus tax. I can’t wait to get my hands on it! I’ve heard it’s truly BIFL quality and dishwasher safe unlike a lot of other pans with non-sealed edges. Are there any other sealed edge clad cookware brands that you recommend as BIFL?


r/cookware 3h ago

Other Hestan ProBond Rims Not Sealed?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I noticed on my new ProBond SS pots and pans after 1-2 dishwasher runs have broken the seal around the rims. Do other users have the same issue? I assumed the metal went the whole way around instead of the seam just being on the bottom of the rim?

I'm wanting to understand if this is expected or not before requesting a replacement and customer service wasn't super helpful


r/cookware 4h ago

Looking for Advice Is this nonstick pan safe?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hey guys, so my brother is telling me that i should throw out this non-stick pan since there are some scratches from metal utensils. I’ve had it less than a year. He’s gotten me a bit paranoid now lol. Does this look toxic?


r/cookware 15h ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Heritage Steel vs. French Classic Cuisinart

3 Upvotes

As title says need some help deciding between two different brands

We've done a lot of research and are torn between the heritage 8 piece set and the French classic 10 piece set

Both seem high to quality and I'm leaning on Heritage due to their customer service and American made and wife is leaning on French classic due to the more elegant appearance and lower cost point

We want Reddit to help us tie break so please give us your choice!

Edit: We went w/ the french set! The deciding factor was the thickness & wife loved the european look of it!

https://www.heritagesteel.us/products/eat-17308?variant=44213753348351

https://www.cuisinart.com/french-classic-tri-ply-stainless-cookware-10-piece-set/FCT-10.html


r/cookware 12h ago

Cleaning/Repair Need help cleaning the handle of pan

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi all, I need to clean off the stains of the handle, etc specifically without damaging the rest of the pan since they're made of different materials. They seem cooked on. Thanks


r/cookware 12h ago

Looking for Advice Kitchen Charm. New thread

0 Upvotes

Can we start a new thread for the Kitchen Charm cookware brand? Like all the others I went to a bridal expo and thought about buying these when I got the message for the demonstration. I didn’t buy it but I’m here the next day on YouTube and Reddit trying to find reviews. YouTube was no help which is concerning. Reddit has old threads. I’d love to get updates from people that bought it years ago. How is it holding up? Have you ever gotten them replaced for free? If it’s worth it maybe I can still buy them.


r/cookware 17h ago

Cleaning/Repair Circulon Hard Anodized skillet

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I found this Circulon Hard Anodized skillet in my house the other day and I’ve been trying to clean it. There’s a black abrasive material on the top which I’m assuming is burn oil that I can’t seem to get off easily. My sister said it’s probably the non-stick coating that is peeling off. I’m wondering if this skillet is salvageable and if so how can I restore it? I’m not familiar with hard anodized cookware. TYIA


r/cookware 22h ago

Looking for Advice New to stainless steel

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’ve bought my first stainless steel pan. I have read a little bit about how to start using it but there are a few that contradict themselves. Can you help me on how to use it properly? Does it need to be season? Thanks for your help.


r/cookware 1d ago

Cooking/appreciation Update: it works!

Post image
59 Upvotes

Took all your sage advice- DID NOT BUY A NON STICK PAN 🙌🏻

Got it nice and hot, did the water droplet test, reduced heat, added a little oil and butter. Smoothest scramble.

Thank you, wise Redditors


r/cookware 1d ago

Looking for Advice Why do my nonstick pans end up looking like this and then sticking?

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

I’ve used 2 non stick pans since the new year (one from Our Place and one from Costco) and they both end up looking like this and are so difficult to clean. Food ends up sticking, defeating the purpose of non stick. I follow the care instructions (low-med heat, oil/butter, wait to put in sink, etc), but it seems impossible. What the heck are we doing wrong?


r/cookware 1d ago

Looking for Advice Anyone having a mini skillet?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

I saw some really cute stainless steel mini skillets, 3.5 to 4.5 inches, at TJ Maxx today. I was debating whether to buy one, but I didn’t because my kitchen is already getting a bit crowded. I wanted to ask and hear about your real experiences.

How worthwhile is it to have a super mini skillet? Will I use it often? The only uses I can think of right now are frying an egg, making a pancake, or simmering sauce.


r/cookware 1d ago

Cleaning/Repair Just picked up this sauce pan at a thrift store, gave it a clean, do yall think it’s safe to use?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/cookware 1d ago

Looking for Advice All Clad D3 SS Pan Cleaned with Scrub Daddy Power Paste

2 Upvotes

Hi all. I’m relatively new to trying anything outside of dish soap, warm water, and regular sponge. I read the sticky on stainless steel pans but I didn’t get an exact answer because I think I messed up.

I bought the Scrub Daddy Power Paste hoping to remove a rainbow-y hue on the cooking side of my All Clad D3 stainless steel set.

I have been using these pots and pans for almost a year now. I’ve never used anything on them aside from dish soap and a regular sponge. They have never leeched anything odd at all. Yesterday, I bought the ScrubDaddy Power Paste Light Citrus Scent paste. Today, I took the dry sponge and some dry paste and scrubbed my pots and pans. They came out looking wonderful, but I noticed my white Scrub sponge was entirely a black-gray hue. I rinsed out the sponge and the pots and pans. I dried it, and the napkin was white.

Did I scrub something important off? The product reads “ideal for pots and pans” but I just now read the finer print that warns “not suitable for stainless steel.”

If the new scratches are all that I have to deal with, that is fine. The bottom of the pans engraving is slightly damaged. I scrubbed the food area of the pan too, which removed the rainbow coating. I’m worried if the residue on my sponge was an important coating. Are they still safe to use to cook food? They look fine now that they’re dry, aside from the scratches and some leftover rainbow residue that I left because I stopped scrubbing out of fear of what was coming off on the sponge. I have a toddler that I cook for in these.


r/cookware 1d ago

Looking for Advice Hestan Nanobond (or other) recommendation please?

3 Upvotes

Hi friends. I recently replaced my cheapo cookware. I don't like buying sets or sticking to one brand. I did some research and bought separate pieces from different brands based on my needs. I really want a Hestan Nanobond cause everyone seems to be raving about this new technology. I've got pretty much all the essential pans already, but I'm wondering if you guys could help me decide what kind of Nanobond pan to get that will fill a role that I don't have covered yet, that the Nanobond would excel in? Or perhaps, suggestions for other pans/brands that you think I should have?

Here's what I have so far:

Lodge 10.25" Cast Iron Skillet - Driver, searing steak
Lodge 11" Cast Iron Skillet - Overflow

Staub 7 qt. Round Cocotte Dutch Oven - Braising, soups, deep frying

Demeyere Atlantis Proline 11" Skillet - Deglazing, acidic foods
Heritage x Eater 8.5" Skillet - Sauteing and tossing, quick glaze, acidic foods, sunny eggs
Heritage x Eater 3 qt. Saucier - Grains, boiling, reducing, reheating
Falk Copper Classic 1.4 qt. Saucier - Temp. sensitive sauces

Some no name 6 qt stockpot - Boiling, pasta, batch grains
8 inch Calphalon non-stick - Eggs, anything sticky
1 qt Calphalon nonstick saucepan - reheating coffee or anything sticky
Some random 10" nitriding cast iron "wok" that I found from TJ Maxx - stir frying

Note I'm just a single amateur dude who normally cooks 1 - 6 servings at a time. Just trying to cover all my bases and complete my set now before the impending tariffs. Thanks in advance!


r/cookware 1d ago

Identification How to identify properties of All Clad saucepan

1 Upvotes

So years ago my wife acquired a 2 qt All-Clad stainless steel saucepan that is devoid of any markings except that it says All Clad on the metal handle. The handle is riveted to the pan with two rivets.

Now that I am learning a little more about cookware I am trying to figure out what I’ve got, is it a 3-ply construction, or something else.

But it doesn’t have any info - even on the underside of the bottom.

Is there any way to figure out what I’ve got?

Thanks in advance!


r/cookware 1d ago

Use/test based review Is it safe to use? Nonstick pan with minor scratches.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Non stick pan having scratch, is it safe to use for cooking? Since its a teflon coating.


r/cookware 1d ago

Identification Help ID’ing a pan

Post image
1 Upvotes

Can y’all help me ID what kind of pan this is? It looks like aluminum but he cooks tomato sauce/wine/lemon juice in these pans all the time which I thought was a no no as aluminum pans are reactive?


r/cookware 1d ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Looking for THAT stainless steel pan

3 Upvotes

Edit: found already but keeping this post up for whoever wants the info! The company is called Darto, and it's carbon steel.The video I was mentioning

Hey everyone. I saw a Youtube Short that glorified this crazy looking brand of stainless steel cookware, but I can't find it anywhere in my history: they said they had no marketing, wrapped their products in plain boxes and brown paper, they're made of one solid piece of steel (maybe it's carbon steel or cast aluminium at this point, which would make more sense for this) so there's no rivets. The finish is matte. Made in the USA. Any ideas? Huge thanks!!


r/cookware 1d ago

Cleaning/Repair Enamel pan, small scratches. Still useable? Will this get worse?

Post image
0 Upvotes

One of my friends used a metal ladle in my pan, despite my advising not to. I don’t see any significant damage but I do see these like hairline scratches, so small I can barely even see them. Is this pan ruined now?


r/cookware 1d ago

Cleaning/Repair Copper Bundt Cake Pan Restore

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

My father in law handed down to us their old family copper Bundt cake pan. We mentioned we were interested in some, more so for hanging decor purposes in our kitchen and he pulled this out of the attic in rough shape. He cleaned with vinegar and it looked night and day better, but he wasn’t satisfied so he bought a copper restore solution (I am not familiar with the product, we were visiting him in Italy) from the store and he put some more elbow grease into it. While the color looks even better still, there are a few dark marks that didn’t appear before the solution was used. Is this something that can be buffed out still or did the solution damage the copper? We are keeping the pan regardless, since it’s an older piece that runs in their family and still looks great but just curious as I am not familiar with copper restoration and if this is normal? Thanks!


r/cookware 2d ago

Seeks specific kitchenware Best Bread Cloche - Not Le Creuset

5 Upvotes

Nothing against le creuset, I just can't afford 200+ bucks for this.

I'd like to get my future sil a bread cloche as a gift, I got mine at Aldi for 25 bucks and it's been a WORKHORSE and I really enjoy the bread i get from it and feel she'd like it too. I'd love to get her the same one, unfortunately, Aldi rotates their stock and I haven't seen it since.

If preferable, looking for a bread cloche. If not, recommendations for best enameled cast iron dutch ovens for about 50-75 usd that are good for bread baking specifically.


r/cookware 1d ago

Other Alternatives to stainless steel

0 Upvotes

This is coming from a non-toxic perspective, as there are concerns with stainless leaching toxic nickel and cadmium into the food. If chemicals are going to leach into food, we would prefer them to be chemicals that are abundantly found in a healthy diet, with unalloyed iron being the most obvious candidate.

The issue with iron as far as I can tell is that it rusts, although I'm not aware of whether rust is actually toxic so maybe that wouldn't be so terrible.

Some people seem to swear by cast iron. However, this is more of an option for shallow pans rather than deep stock pots. There are other concerns about cast iron, such as its heat conductivity. The same concern is for ceramics.

Finally, there are the coated pans. Obviously, we dont want PFAS in the coatings, but neither do we want lead paint, as many enamel coatings contain. It's not clear to me why an enamel coating needs to contain paint at all, since fused silica would be naturally non-toxic and would never leach into food.

In summary, it seems like there are options for non-toxic cookware (and particularly large stock pots), but these options are not popular largely for cosmetic reasons (rust bad, paint good). Those who truly seek non-toxic cookware would do best to make their own.


r/cookware 2d ago

New Acquisition Scored copper core for 20 bucks

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Along with a griddled and waffle irons (50 bucks)