r/self 6d ago

I can smell when people have cancer

Believe it or not, I can smell when someone has cancer. It is the most pungent smell ever, and only gets worse the stronger it is. As a child, my grandpa started smelling funny, and after a while he was diagnosed with cancer. The smell got stronger as his cancer did, until he passed away. I thought nothing of it until my Nan on the other side started smelling the same way, and it got stronger until she eventually got diagnosed and passed away too. That’s when I started thinking wait maybe I can smell cancer (or maybe it’s just a coincidence). I started smelling the smell at varying strengths for people in public, and always kinda thought in the back of my head oh man I think they’ve got cancer. However, it wasn’t until my OTHER granddad got cancer and had to stay in hospital and at 17 I got to go visit him in a hospice specifically for cancer patients. I could hardly walk in the building. There it was again - that SMELL! Do people secrete certain chemicals when they have cancer? I have a strong sense of smell so I could possibly pick up on it. It’s definitely not when they’re going through chemo, because I can smell it on people who haven’t started chemo yet. I am genuinely going crazy trying to find an answer. This smell is horrendous and I just don’t understand why I can smell it when nobody else seemingly can??

Edit: on a long car journey rn, feeling a bit car sick so won’t be replying to any more comments for a while. This isn’t an April fools, I’ll repost it tomorrow if u really don’t believe! Will be contacting more research places too :)

52.2k Upvotes

9.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.1k

u/Zealousideal_Star252 6d ago

Honestly, I would keep reaching out to other researchers outside your area. Even if this isn't what you think it is (and as other commenters have pointed out, it's possible that is IS, weirder things have happened) something unique is definitely going on with you. Best case scenario, we have discovered potentially a new research weapon in the fight against cancer. Worst case scenario, you have a bizarre unknown condition yourself that causes you to experience these smells.

Either way, it's scientifically fascinating and potentially medically important, and someone will want to study it. Don't let one group of researchers being dismissive make you give up. If nothing else, you deserve the chance to find medical answers for yourself and the symptoms you're experiencing, as it's causing you concern.

1.5k

u/ikeda1 5d ago edited 5d ago

There is a woman who can smell Parkinson's before someone is even symptomatic. She ended up connecting with researchers and they are working on isolating the exact chemical make-upshe is picking up on.

https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/03/23/820274501/her-incredible-sense-of-smell-is-helping-scientists-find-new-ways-to-diagnose-di

Maybe the researchers she is working with would be worth reaching out to.

466

u/North_Apple_6014 5d ago

This. I would reach out to the folks who work with the Parkinson’s woman and they should be more helpful. 

714

u/clappingcactus 5d ago

u/calm-cucumber-252, I can help get in touch with the original researchers that interacted with Joy Milne.

195

u/Own_Exercise_2520 5d ago

Should dm them their notifications on reddit may bury this

26

u/FUTURE10S 5d ago

I mean, unless they're on old Reddit, then any notification gets buried. Perhaps it's best to just DM their inbox.

87

u/DangNearRekdit 5d ago

Reddit did indeed bury this. 29 upvotes and I still had to click the + sign

57

u/clappingcactus 5d ago

Alright, I pm'ed op.

32

u/chuthulu_but_gayer 5d ago

Gotta update us!

2

u/thisisaddictiveoff 4d ago

Yes! I need to know where this goes!

4

u/nokipokr 5d ago

So cool!! I hope they research this ability!! It'd be great to learn what's going on

3

u/DenizenEvil 5d ago

Might be worth PM'ing again in a week so that OP's inbox isn't being blown up by replies to the thread. This is something potentially important enough to keep trying.

1

u/dyinglittlestar 5d ago

Would love to hear any updates of these later!!

1

u/Icing_on_the_Trauma 1d ago

Please tell me you got into contact with this person!! I’m just so hopeful for a better world with people like this in it.

7

u/DesireeThymes 5d ago

Please DM them. Any breakthroughs in cancer are good for all of us.

5

u/Halt96 5d ago

Or if you're US based, Richard Doty, the director of the Smell and Taste Center at the University of Pennsylvania's Perelman School of Medicine might also be a good contact.

3

u/Eager_DRZ 2d ago

I saw him mentioned in the article posted about Parkinson’s. Also Dr. Thomas Hummel of the Technical University of Dresden’s Smell & Taste Clinic was mentioned. I thought they’d both be good contacts. Probably could give recommendations even if not themselves interested.

That Parkinson’s article also mentioned dogs have been shown to identify cancer by smell. So why not humans? The researchers working on that might be interested in talking to the OP. https://faseb.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1096/fasebj.2019.33.1_supplement.635.10

4

u/TorpeAlex 5d ago

Upvoting and replying to signal boost this, u/calm-cucumber-252!

2

u/ChampagneWastedPanda 5d ago

Moments like these make me love reddit

2

u/Alarmed_Profile1950 5d ago

I think I can do it too. The only person I know with cancer is me atm, so sample size is small, but willing to help in any way I can.

1

u/ZempOh 5d ago

Amazing!

1

u/skeleton_inside_u 5d ago

Wonderful, stuff like this is what Reddit was made for, best of luck

1

u/Rossfire 5d ago

This is why I Reddit

1

u/5-ht2ayyy 5d ago

This is sooooo cool to see happen!

Can anybody explain to me how to set the remind me function??

1

u/AlphaPuz 3d ago

I’d like to know too. Fascinating stuff going on here

1

u/ProfessionalCry5162 5d ago

Gotta bump this comment up up up!

1

u/Twinkies100 5d ago

world is a small place

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

Oh yeah, scientists love getting tips from morons off reddit 🙄

0

u/clappingcactus 4d ago

Scientists love everything equally, from my personal views on the matter. ;)

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

Scientists don't take stories on social media seriously, you know, lack of evidence..

1

u/asutoriddo 2d ago

All it takes is a curious mind and the right eyes to see it.

1

u/shakila1408 1d ago

Absolutely!

1

u/fapizoid 4d ago

RemindMe! 6 months

1

u/Assistant-Thin 3d ago

RemindMe! 6 months

1

u/slipperyinit 2d ago

Did you manage?

1

u/clappingcactus 1d ago

No :/ I even re-messaged yesterday. I had two other users reach out for the same reason, so I'll try to get them in touch instead but u/Calm-Cucumber-252 isn't responding to me.