As an autistic person, it’s aways infuriated me when someone video tapes telling their kids they’re going to Disneyland and then records their emotional breakdown. Or giving children a puppy and watching them cry and freak out.
To me, this feels not only exploitative but emotionally unhealthy.
Both of my kids are getting older (double digits), but when they were younger, people kept trying to “surprise” them with gifts or jumping out with a sense of fun from behind things and I had to constantly remind people not to do these things. My kids have learned (after years of being coached by myself and my spouse), how to thank people for gifts they don’t like, but you’re not going to get them to do performative fawning or excitement. And I honestly don’t believe that a person should expect that kind of reaction, especially not from an autistic child.
I prepare my kids for exciting things like birthday parties and trips to Disneyland. I get them involved because they are better at transitioning between tasks and events when they know what to expect and feel ownership.
I absolutely hate it when people spring surprises on them and then get shitty about their overwhelmed response. I can explain it until I turn blue but so many other adults seem to think they know best and then get upset when their expectations aren’t met.
I know from personal experience and plenty of skill building just how hard it can be for me to manage my emotions and expectations around a change, especially changes that I have no control over. Small things like packaging or ingredient changes can be enough to ruin my taste for food items, and larger changes, like long time stores closing or the loss of an aging pet or family member, can be nearly impossible to fully get over.
Our family processes everything deeply and that is why the only “surprises” that really land well are between two knowns.
For example, I might ask “would you like (item kid 1 likes) or (other item kid 1 likes)”? And at this point, the kids deeply trust my partner and I to know what they like and respect their interests, so even if it’s not exactly what is expected, they generally know they will receive clothes that are sensory friendly and shoes that are wide enough to fit their feet. They have even become more flexible about trying new food once they realized they had ironclad control over what they eat.
So please. I know that many parents and adults think that kids love surprises, but if we tell you that our kids don’t, regardless of who that kid is, please listen to us. Our kids love “spoilers” because it helps us feel comfortable and in control. Our kids love multiple little chats about what to expect from a big trip or event two weeks in the future.
Surprises may seem like magic to a lot of kids out there, but some kids love a different kind of magic, and that’s ok too.