To preface, I hope this does not turn into yet another political discussion.
For the S and P, using Y charts, adding up the earnings from last 4 quarters, I am getting 200.
Per a 2020 Goldman investor letter, the average recession is associated with 17.5% EPS reduction. On average the S and P returns about 9% per year over last 20 years.
CAPE ratio of the S and P is 31 currently.
So, I am modeling the S and P based on fundamentals and sentiment.
For fundamentals, I have 3 scenarios: bear scenario where a 17.5% (from Goldman letter) EPS reduction occurs, base with no change in EPS, bull with 9% increase in EPS.
For sentiment, I have same 3 scenarios: bear PE 25, base PE 30 (slight decline in sentiment) , bull PE 33.
So, in the bearish scenario, EPS is 165 (17% reduction in EPS) and PE 25. which yields a price of 4125.
Base scenario, EPS of 200 with PE of 30 yields a price of 6000.
Most bullish scenario EPS 218 (9% growth), PE 33. yields 7194.
Of note the historical median CAPE is 16. Assuming EPS 200 (no growth), this yields 3200. Which to me makes no sense. I think the issue is this includes all the time period before globalized free trade and dollar based system. But this could be seen as the black swan come to reality number.
Bottomline:
I think the tariffs will be rolled back, delayed, forgotten. Victories will be proclaimed. Parallel imports will cushion the blow as well. Get ready for British tooth brushes, Brazilian MRI machines, Canadian Kimchee and Mexican Rolex Submariner and ALS 1815 Up/down definitely USMCA compliant.
Jokes aside, for me, I will start buying around 4500-4600. Aim to deploy all dry powder if we ever hit 4100. We certainly can dip below 4000 but to me very unlikely.
We have had enough orange idiot comments or orange savior comments. I have zero interest in American politics. Let's just stick to the stocks and what you think the numbers will be and why. I know no one can predict the future, but I think nonetheless it is important to build a framework to guide our investment decisions.