My partner (29m) and I (28f) have been together for 5 years. We love each other a lot and have a ton of similar interests, but I am a hopeless romantic and he is an adhd bad planner, the kind of person to forget about birthdays and not ever plan dates. He is also easily embarrassed in crowds and does not love being the center of a lot of peoples attention. We’re already in a domestic partnership and have talked a lot about getting engaged. I’ve always dreamed of a romantic proposal, anything that gives us that emotional special moment and shows his effort/planning and represents us as a couple.
He’s asked what I want and I’ve been direct to make it simple: maybe 1 member of my family popping out to celebrate after, to hear something authentic from him, a surprise photographer who he’d vibe with, to look decent on that day, but really for him to be the planner in charge. I am the eldest daughter and always the one forced to plan trips, blamed if things go wrong, and I just wanted one day for myself to feel loved.
We’ve been on an international trip now for 2 weeks, week 1 in a different country than now. We had a big argument there after he didn’t help plan anything for our itinerary, procrastinated packing and logistics so I did everything, and just didn’t feel like we were in it together. In a moment where I was down, I said “I hope you’re not planning to propose soon, because I’m not ready to say yes until we can lean on each other for support”. We resolved things and have actively tried to compromise more.
In our current country, we’re visiting my grandparents who I was close to growing up, and my mom and much younger sister joined for a week from the US since none of us had seen grandparents since pre-Covid. My mom/sister/bf and I did a day trip to a very touristy place (think a UNESCO site), grandparents decided not to come because they were tired. I was ready for a hike up, had my camera gear on me, and was really excited to experience this spot with bf. Bf and I went ahead to grab a snack at the gate, then my mom showed up with “a family friend of your aunt who is a photographer building his portfolio who wants a few pics of you guys for his social media”. Bf seems surprised and uncomfortable, but my mom is also very controlling/demanding, so we give in. Bf then spills a few drops of coffee on his shirt, and my mom INSISTS that we buy ridiculous souvenir shirts to wear instead. I adamantly refuse, bf hates souvenirs like that, he despises persistent salespeople, she forces us both to try one on, buys them anyways and insists he wears his. He doesn’t but now feels awkward, I laugh about the coffee stain bc we’re both clumsy and it’s endearing.
We start walking up and photog is nonstop snapping photos of us. Me drinking water. Bf putting on a jacket, two feet away from his face. It’s extremely uncomfortable. Bf tells me it’s annoying and it’s like paparazzi following him.
Bf and I are both getting extremely peeved and just want to be left alone but mom says to not be rude and that it would be disrespectful to my aunt to treat her friend like that. I can tell my introverted bf is nearing his limit and I continue asking the photographer to leave us be. We get to the top and I want to enjoy the view and talk to bf about it, photog will not leave us alone. I’m ready to scream in his face, I feel gross and sweaty, and want to just explore around. I know my bf is introverted and I can tell he is not loving this.
We continue along the path to the next viewpoint, I turn to grab something and then I turn around and bf is suddenly on one knee. I asked him later on why there wasn’t any buildup and he said it was because the photographers gestured him to go at that moment for their shots and he wasn’t prepared yet so he rushed. At this point I am dressed in all black dirty clothes, pissed off at this photographer who won’t leave us alone, haven’t gotten a single moment alone to enjoy the day with bf, had just told him a week ago I needed some more time to feel secure, and there was no buildup at all to him being on one knee so I’m shocked. I panic and the first words out of my mouth are “no no no no not like this I’m not ready”. He looks panicked, starts saying “oh-“ and getting up awkwardly, then I realize there are 4 MORE PHOTOGRAPHERS/VIDEOGRAPHERS suddenly all within 10ft. I’m about to shrivel up because I know that this happens once, I’ve envisioned it a hundred ways but not like this, and now there’s a ton of pressure and people watching, we both feel awkward, and one of the guys runs over to clip a mic on bf, which is a nightmare to him. He makes the world’s shortest proposal speech, I barely process what’s happening, I say yes, everyone cheers, we kiss, I am dying inside. We are then forced to take a million posed photos, bf already hates taking photos, he has no idea what’s going on because they’re all yelling at him in a different language and I’m trying to translate, we both have photo fatigue, I feel ugly and terrible, and want to run away and cry. There was a whole damn bag of clean laundry in the car, I wish I’d worn literally anything else - jeans, t shirt, hoodie, sundress, literally anything that wasn’t black leggings where you can see my pantylines and a black thermal shirt I hadn’t washed for 3 days. I felt hideous and wanted to hide. We get down 2 hours later and we are both not feeling great, like the whole damn day was a modeling job we didn’t get paid for. I try to explain to my mom that the photographer should not have followed us up the whole time if this was a surprise, she scolds that the guy said it would make for a better “story video” (bf asked for help weeks ago and then got no say or info on anything, and literally told my mom it was a bad idea for photog to follow us up and would ruin his surprise, she let them anyways because she thought it’d be better). Bf thought grandparents were coming and it would mean a lot to me which it absolutely would’ve, then my mom/aunt didn’t tell him they weren’t. I try to gently tell aunt that it didn’t go great and we felt uncomfortable, she shuts me down with “we all tried so hard to make this great, it was a lot of work for ME to plan, you should have a better attitude.” Mom says “you should be happy - don’t be picky, sometimes you have to think about other people too and their feelings” (meaning her/my aunt/the photography team/my uncle/the salespeople at the gift shop, never once does she actually mention MY BF and MY feelings). We get driven to a fancy restaurant that uncle picked “for us” that my bf wasn’t aware of at all, we tell them we need a few minutes privately to celebrate for the first time all day. They’re annoyed but go in, I immediately start crying in the parking lot from feeling overwhelmed and bf understood why and felt similarly. Within 5 minutes, mom comes out to scold us and say “don’t embarrass your uncle, you’re humiliating yourself, hurry up, you’re being so annoying”. The dinner doesn’t feel celebratory, it mostly feels like a way for my uncle to show off because he’s wealthy and loves to play host while everyone praises how good a job he did. Bf is very lowkey and we’re just not fancy restaurant people but didn’t get any say in it.
Bf and I get back to the hotel and I cry until I fall asleep. I feel guilty about not giving him his dream reaction and that his plans didn’t go as he expected. He thought only 1 photographer would be at the top, that my grandparents would be there, and that he’d be more involved in getting to choose things. I wish he did the planning himself instead of relying on others. Over the next few hours, bf asked if I meant the yes and if he could try again, more privately, where he’d arrange everything his way with no outside input, because he wants to give us our fairytale moment. This is what I wanted all along. He used a placeholder ring since we want to pick the real one together, and wants to officially repropose once we pick one out.
It’s been a few days now and it’s very meaningful to me that he was so apologetic and understood where he screwed up, but I am still bummed for us. I’m mad that this was probably all very expensive and that it wasn’t a good experience for bf either. I am angry that my mom keeps saying to be grateful, that it was hard for her and my aunt, yet they kept my bf so out of the loop and didn’t even give him the chance for input or help! My bf loves silly nerdy things like pokemon and cats and video games, they’re a big part of our lives together, and my mom frequently calls those things dumb and immature - he never got the opportunity to make this his own. Even now, the photographer has only communicated with my aunt, and she sent a few to the family chat with “they gave me the album so I picked a few to show you guys!” My bf feels like they’re treating us like children and he was completely pushed out.
I don’t care how selfish this makes me, but this was supposed to be a special day for us. I don’t know if it’s stupid to want a reproposal, but I just want to think of this one as a practice run. It wasn’t about the actual proposal, it was about wanting to feel like I could prioritize my wants for once (taking our time to celebrate together our way, not worrying about someone else’s dinner reservations, getting to have our silly moments, being spontaneous rather than unnatural photo posing that the photographer insisted on). I know this isn’t the end of the world and we will have a long happy life together, but I wanted this romantic moment so badly where we got to just take each other in. I’m disappointed that both of us felt so rushed, no one told him about my grandparents not being there, he didn’t get to make the speech he wanted, there were too many cameras in his face, he had no idea what anyone was saying, no one filled him in. I love him more now for recognizing my feelings, having a conversation with me to process, and wanting to try again for both of us to feel fulfilled. It makes me realize even more that we do have a lot of the same things in common (and some of the same pet peeves lol)
TLDR: had an awkward proposal where a lot of things went wrong, bf overtrusted my family to plan everything in a different country, they didn’t fill him in at all, overbearing photographer ruined the day, family is gaslighting, and I needed to vent. I’m still trying to process the day that happened. Bf wants to try again and do it his way more privately, I’d love to feel an authentic moment with him and just enjoy each other, everyone else in the family thinks we had a great time. I’m still sad it happened the way it did, but somehow we feel closer to each other now.
reposted with more details on partners personality and why this was a nightmare for him