Hello, everyone! This is actually my first Reddit post ever so bear with me. I am 23 and live in Florida, any advice would be sincerely appreciated. I haven't dealt with this kind of financial situation before, but let me know of this post belongs in a legal advice subreddit instead of financial advice.
There is a lot of context surrounding my worries for this scenario so I apologize for the wordiness. It's related to credit, debt, and apartment eligibility. I separated this into parts to signify related chunks of context, but scroll down for the TLDR. Thank you for your time!
Long story:
1) Last year I used to work at a full body auto shop, which was visited by a Matco Tools distributor (I'm sure you can guess where this is going). I had thought I was making a worthy investment opening a credit account and buying tools, but I set a foot in my grave by adding a $2,500 tool box with the purchase. Not only did I realize just how deadly the interest rate was, but I ended up quitting the mechanic world much sooner than I thought due to medical issues. So there I was, stuck with a $4k purchase to pay off- which became $8k with interest.
Quite a few months later, I had no hope of keeping up with these payments. I decided to have my tools voluntarily repossessed in hopes that the market resale value would knock down what I owed by a decent amount. It did not. They couldn't get a hold of the original distributor for a good few months too, which stacked up some late fees on top of what I owed. My balance ended up just dropping to ~$3,400 after the process.
2) After all this, I was on a call with a Matco representative being honest about not being able to pay, and trying to negotiate a plan. They even sliced it in half- offering a one-time full payment of ~$1,700 to close up this ordeal. But this was still more money than I had in my entire bank account.
The representative had explained that if I fail to pay, Matco hands this business to a debt collection agency and my credit score gets affected negatively. But they repeated several times throughout the (recorded) call, "I can't tell you that you can do nothing, ok?" Like a reassurance. So I took it as I'm risking my job by telling you that you will be ok doing nothing. So I decided to go with my gut and their word, and take no action to pay.
3) Regarding my credit I think I have done very well so far, even though my length of credit is just two years: My score was 756 when I got my first dealership car in July of 2023 (causing 2 hard inquiries ofc). I have rent reporting enabled for rent on my apartment. I have never missed a single payment on my credit card, auto loan, or rent, and I have always stayed way below 30% usage on my credit card. I also don't let my balance roll onto the next month, I just pay it off manually on the same day each month before the credit is reported.
On Discover it lists 3 total accounts, N/A revolving utilization, 0 inquiries, and 1 serious delinquency from the tool situation. My AMEX (in which my parents are primary card holders, always paid on time) report shows 4 open, good standing accounts, and 1 closed derogatory account. It reports that my Matco credit account was closed in December 2024 with a high balance, with the pay status listed as "charge-off." At the time around the repossession of my tools, my credit score had dwindled to 701, then down to 600. I actually have no idea why it dropped that bad unless it was just the repossession, because I saw nothing else affecting my score negatively on my credit report.
4) Anyways, about 4-5 months pass since the call with the representative, and I'm just going about my life working and stuff. My credit scores slowly inch back up. Then I get a missed call from Weltman Weinberg and Reis Co. LPA representing Matco. The debt collector. At the same time, my FICO credit score gets dunked by 25 points for a major delinquent account factor related to my defaulting payments. I check my credit scores: Discover is down to 608, and AMEX sunk to 562 (this account was opened by my parents for me like two months ago, and the score started at 585).
This is one last bit of context to explain my current situation and why this history affects it. So November 30, 2025 is the end of my lease. I live with 4 friends (1 being my partner), in which we were all originally planning on moving out of state together by the end of the lease. Then, my partner recently received a job offer here in Florida. If this opportunity proves to be worthwhile, we would stick around for 1-2 years longer. Our two friends are moving out of state no matter what due to family, so in the scenario that we would separate, my partner and I would be moving to a different apartment here come November. (Questions below TLDR).
...
TLDR: I'm 23, live in Florida. I had my tools voluntarily repossessed by MATCO but couldn't afford to pay off the remaining balance even after the market resale reduced it to ~$3,400, so I took no action to pay. I got a call from a debt collector representing MATCO many months later (now), and my credit score was docked 25 points with a serious delinquent account status. My roommates and I are moving out of Florida by this November, and currently my credit score is 562 (AMEX) and 608 (Discover).
Question 1&2: Is it a bad idea to ignore the debt collector? I am deathly afraid of legal actions they can take, like suing me to get the remaining balance paid. I have no means of paying off the balance whatsoever, but is it worth calling back even to negotiate a lower payment? I would really only want to do that if I can make sure they remove the delinquent status from my credit accounts like a delete letter, but that may be highly unlikely if I can't pay the full intended balance.
Question 3: Is it likely that my credit score will reach or surpass 600 again by this November? My next worry besides the debt collector is being able to be qualified to get an apartment, as most require a credit score above 600. So I am wondering if paying the remaining balance (if reduced) and removing the delinquent status will help my score rise faster, or if none of that matters and it's likely to go back up in time anyways.
Thank you to anyone putting consideration into this post. Have a wonderful day!
Edit: I checked out the "Dealing with collections" and "Credit repair" links from the automod and they provided extremely useful information! I would still like feedback and opinions on my questions if possible. Thank you :)